Stephanie Fernandes and Denna Jalili analyze a series of recent Ontario CCAA decisions examining the scope and appropriateness of third-party releases, highlighting renewed judicial scrutiny of overly broad protections following Justice Black’s warning against handing out releases “like Halloween candy” in SRx Health Solutions and Justice Myers’ criticism of releases that unfairly distinguish between objecting and non-objecting creditors in Paystone, while contrasting those decisions with Field Aviation and Freshstone, where courts approved releases supported by evidence of meaningful restructuring contributions, emphasizing that even broadly worded releases may be permissible where they are proportionate, rationally connected to the restructuring and justified under the Lydian factors.








