Canada (Attorney General) v. HealthHub Patient Engagement Solutions Inc., 2026 NSCA 83
Can employees transferred to a residual company under a reverse vesting order qualify for the Wage Earner Protection Program?
Summary: The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal dismissed the Attorney General of Canada's appeal of an order allowing employees terminated following a reverse vesting transaction to apply for benefits under the Wage Earner Protection Program. The Court upheld the finding that a Residual Co. that assumed employment-related liabilities and terminated the affected employees could qualify as their former employer for the purposes of the Program, rejecting an interpretation that would deny workers access to wage protection based on whether an insolvent business was restructured through an asset sale or a reverse vesting transaction. The Court also considered the implications of that distinction for the approval of reverse vesting transactions under the Harte Gold framework.
HealthHub Patient Engagement Solutions Inc. (“HealthHub”) provides televisions, patient entertainment terminals and software designed to improve hospital efficiency to healthcare facilities across Canada. HealthHub filed a notice of intention to make a proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (the “BIA”) after its primary operating lender, the Toronto-Dominion Bank (“TD Bank”), delivered notices to enforce security. Grant Thornton Limited was appointed as proposal trustee. Following a marketing process, the proposal trustee determined that the only viable transaction that would maximize value was a credit bid by an Ontario numbered company that had acquired TD Bank’s security, structured as a purchase of HealthHub’s shares through a reverse vesting transaction.
On December 19, 2025, Justice Bodurtha of the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia granted a reverse vesting order approving the acquisition of HealthHub (the “RVO”). Certain assets and liabilities were excluded from the purchase and transferred to a newly incorporated company (“Residual Co.”), including liabilities relating to employees who were to be terminated. The transaction closed on December 25, 2025. The affected employees were transferred to Residual Co. and then terminated. On December 29, 2025, Residual Co. was deemed to have made an assignment in bankruptcy.
Paragraph 33 of the RVO declared that Residual Co. met the criteria prescribed by section 3.2 of the Wage Earner Protection Program Regulations and that its employees could apply for benefits under the Wage Earner Protection Program (the “Program”). It also deemed Residual Co. to be the “former employer”, for specified Program purposes, of former HealthHub employees whose claims were transferred to Residual Co. and whose employment was subsequently terminated.
The Attorney General of Canada (“AGC”) sought and was granted leave to appeal the WEPPA relief in paragraph 33 of the RVO on two principal grounds:
The motions judge lacked jurisdiction to deem Residual Co. the former employer of the terminated employees; and
The motions judge erred in finding that Residual Co. was their former employer such that the applicable statutory and regulatory criteria were met.
Section 5(5) of the Wage Earner Protection Program Act (the “Act”) authorizes a court in BIA proposal or CCAA proceedings to determine whether a former employer meets the prescribed criteria. The Attorney General argued that the judge could determine whether the former employer met those criteria, but not who the former employer was. The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal (the “Court”) rejected that argument. Determining whether an employer meets the prescribed criteria necessarily requires the court to first identify the relevant employer. The Attorney General's argument conflated the judge's jurisdiction to determine the issue with whether the judge had decided it correctly.
The remaining issue was whether Residual Co. could be deemed the terminated employees’ “former employer” under the Act. The Attorney General argued that the employees had historically performed services for HealthHub, not Residual Co., and that the Program was not intended to support a restructuring in which HealthHub continued operating. The Court found that this interpretation overlooked the effect of the Order. The employee liabilities had been transferred to Residual Co., which then terminated the employees. Although the relationship was not a typical employer-employee relationship, those steps made Residual Co. their “former employer” within the statutory scheme.
The Court found that this interpretation was consistent with the Program’s purpose. The Program is a safety net for employees owed wages by insolvent employers, providing prompt payment of eligible wages rather than requiring workers to await an uncertain insolvency distribution. As benefits-conferring legislation, the Act should receive a broad and generous interpretation. The Court also considered the amendments to the Act which extended the Program beyond bankruptcies and receiverships to qualifying proposal and CCAA proceedings. Those amendments reflected Parliament’s recognition that employees suffer the same economic harm whether an insolvency proceeds through liquidation, proposal or restructuring, and worker protection should operate flexibly across all such contexts.
The Attorney General also argued that Residual Co. had no assets from which the government could recover payments made under the Program through its subrogation rights. Under section 36 of the Act, those rights allow the government to pursue an employee’s wage claim against the insolvent employer, up to the amount paid. The Court noted that recovery may likewise be unavailable in a traditional liquidation. Nothing in the legislation makes worker protection contingent on the government’s prospect of recovery.
The Court found that the Attorney General’s interpretation would produce an arbitrary distinction based on transaction structure. Employees terminated following an asset sale could access the Program, while employees in the same position following a reverse vesting transaction could not. Parliament could not have intended that distinction.
That interpretation would also weaken worker protection and make reverse vesting transactions harder to approve. Under the Harte Gold framework, courts assess whether stakeholders would be worse off under a proposed transaction than under another viable alternative. Denying employees access to the Program solely because of the transaction structure could undermine that assessment.
The Court drew an analogy to Rizzo & Rizzo Shoes Ltd. (Re), where the Supreme Court rejected an interpretation that denied termination and severance pay because employment ended through bankruptcy rather than by the employer. The Court noted a similarly absurd result here as employees would lose wage protection because of the transaction structure, despite facing the same loss of employment. In the Court’s view, that interpretation would defeat the wage loss mitigation purpose of the Act.
Accordingly, the Court upheld the finding that Residual Co. was a former employer for the purposes of the Act, allowing the affected employees to apply for benefits under the Program. The appeal was dismissed without costs.
Judges: Bryson J.A., with Farrar and Bourgeois JJ.A. concurring.
Professionals involved:
Harvey Chaiton and Maleeha Anwar of Chaitons for HealthHub Patient Engagement Solutions Inc.
Deanna Frappier and Sophie Dupré for the Attorney General of Canada







